David Bentley Hart: An Orthodox Easter

This also included some observations on Holy Week so I thought I might risk talking about Easter before Holy Week has come to a finale. HT: Wall Street Journal

An Orthodox Easter
Expressive extravagance, dramaturgical splendor.

By DAVID B. HART
Friday, A

pril 9, 2004 12:01 A.M. EDT

This is one of those rare years when Christians of the Eastern and Western communions will celebrate Easter on the same Sunday. For those of us who–in quixotic moments–blow upon the gray embers of our hopes for a reunited Church, this is always an especially happy occasion. We may not all be entering into the mysteries of Christ’s death and resurrection as one, but at least this year we are doing it at the same time.

After all, one of those tiresome platitudes that hovers over the division between the ancient churches is that, whereas Eastern Orthodox tradition principally emphasizes the resurrection of Christ, Catholic (and Protestant) tradition principally emphasizes his death. The one, it is said, proclaims more a “theology of glory”; the other, more a “theology of the cross.”

There may be some truth in this, but not much. The more deeply one ventures into either tradition, the more one grasps the inseparability in both of Christ’s passion and glorification, his sacrifice and his victory. And it is in just these rare years when our two Paschal calendars coincide–when we mourn and rejoice together–that this commonality seems especially evident.

One genuinely pronounced difference between East and West does, however, become obvious at these times: that of liturgical sensibility. Nor is this insignificant. How we worship very much determines how we “see” the suffering or risen Christ in our devotions.

To those unfamiliar with Orthodox worship, it is difficult to convey a proper sense of its sheer expressive extravagance–its dramaturgical splendor, its combination of the mystical and the spectacular, its profusion of symbols, poetry and large forceful gestures. The churches are lavishly adorned with icons, the entire liturgy is sung, the services are long and intricate, and everything (if well executed) is utterly absorbing.

And during Holy Week (or Passion Week, as it is called in the East), all this liturgical exorbitance reaches its climax. As the week progresses, worship becomes all but continuous, morning and evening, culminating in three magnificent services in which is concentrated all the dramatic genius of Byzantine liturgy.

On Friday night, the service of Lamentation is celebrated. An image of the dead Christ is laid in his funeral bier (ornately carved, copiously decorated with flowers), and shatteringly powerful hymns of mourning are sung over him. The bier is then borne in procession around the outside of the church; briefly, the church doors become the gates of Hades, upon which the priest beats with the book of the Gospels to announce the arrival of the Lord of Glory, who comes to plunder death of its captives.

The eucharistic liturgy on Saturday morning is an unapologetic exercise in triumphalism. Its governing theme is Christ’s conquest of death, sin and the devil, and his harrowing of hell. At one point, in fact, the priest passes through the congregation flinging bay leaves to every side as a symbol of Christ’s victory.

And this same triumphalism pervades the Easter Vigil that begins that same night and continues on well into the early hours of Easter morning. At the moment of highest drama, at midnight, all the lights in the church are extinguished, and the faithful wait in total darkness. The priest then bears a lighted candle in through the central door of the great icon screen behind which the altar is hidden, as a symbol of the risen Christ departing from his tomb, and summons the congregation to light the candles they have brought with them from this flame.

Thereafter, the liturgy is all light and joy, punctuated by frequent repetitions of the great Paschal hymn–“Christ is risen from the dead, trampling down death by death, and to those in the tombs restoring life!” And (incredibly enough) a feast follows.

As I have said, one must experience such worship to understand its profundity. I can say only that, in my two decades of being Orthodox, the power of these services has not diminished in the least; and every year, at one point or another, I become entirely lost in the glory of the Gospel being announced and portrayed before my eyes.

And as, again, this is one of those years when one can almost deceive oneself that the churches are united, I might finish by recommending an Eastern custom to all Christians, of every communion. For 40 days following Easter, the Orthodox greet one another with the words “Christ is risen!” To which the correct response is “He is risen indeed!”

Advertisements

11 Comments

  1. Reed,

    Atheist Delusions is the first of Hart’s books that I’ve read, but I’m definitely interested in his other work. One of my clergy colleagues echoes your enthusiasm for The Beauty of the Infinite. I’ll check it out.

    Holy Week blessings,
    Bryan+

    Reply

  2. I’m trying to convince my wife that we ought to convert to a high church, but she’s a tough cookie ;-).

    Grad school is one year away yet, so we have a bit of time to brainstorm… ;-).

    Reply

  3. It is usually relatively easy to convince even a low-churcher to go Anglican. We have a reputation for being the Protestant stepping stone to higher churches!

    Reply

  4. My wife is more keen on the Presbyterians, and I am more keen on the Orthodox/Catholic churches, so perhaps the Anglicans can be the via media ;-).

    My friend here at Calvin College just got accepted to Princeton Seminary, and is in the process of ordination in the Episcopal church. He advised me semi-strongly to consider a different communion, LOL.

    R.R. Reno converted from Anglican to Catholic (in 2006?). So while I like the Anglicans, we’ll see ;-).

    Reply

  5. Ugh…Presbyterians 😉

    If I was to be a layman it would most likely be Orthodoxy for me. It would be a hard sell though ’cause my wife would not be keen. Believe me I completely understand and sympathize with Anglican reservations.

    Reply

  6. The problem is that my wife was raised Baptist, and we both now come from a charismatic low-church tradition, so Presbyterian is already a big jump for her, hehe.

    Reply

  7. My wife is a preacher’s kid from the non-denominational Christian Church/Church of Christ. She wasn’t too keen on going to St. Alban’s Episcopal at first.

    So you can imagine how happy it made me when we visited a non-denominational evangelical church and she said “You know…I think you might be right that church needs to be a little deeper.”

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s